The Plain White T-Shirt: The Hardest Thing to Get Right
The Plain White T-Shirt: The Hardest Thing to Get Right
Only a perfect pattern & perfect fabric, no hardware, nowhere to hide.
It Was Underwear
The short sleeved, buttonless shirt we all wear turned up around 1900. The U.S. Navy was issuing it as a standard undershirt by 1913, white cotton, crew neck, cheap and easy to wash and cool enough for a boiler room. Sailors and marines stripped off the uniform jacket and worked in it.
The word itself entered print in 1920, when F. Scott Fitzgerald listed a T-shirt among a young man's packing for New England in This Side of Paradise. By 1938 a mail order catalog sold them for twenty four cents. It was not clothing. It was what went under clothing.
Then a war ended and millions of men came home with them. They wore them out of the house with uniform trousers, because that is what they owned, and the taboo against showing an undergarment weakened one street at a time.
Four Years That Changed It
In 1951 Marlon Brando played Stanley Kowalski in A Streetcar Named Desire in a thin white tee, and it read as raw and dangerous rather than domestic. In 1955 James Dean wore one in Rebel Without a Cause with jeans, and the plain white tee became the uniform of refusing to fall in line.
Four years. Underwear to outerwear. No other garment has ever made that jump so fast, and nothing has replaced it since. Every graphic tee, band shirt, protest shirt and campaign shirt on earth is a descendant of that plain white piece of Navy issue.
Why It Is Hard
A jacket can hide a lot. Hardware, lining, a good cloth, a strong silhouette. A white tee has nothing. No pattern, no hardware, no distraction. All you see is the yarn, the knit, the collar and the cut. Every shortcut shows.
Most tees are made to a price and it is visible in about three washes. The body twists. The collar goes wavy and never comes back. The hem curls. The cotton pills across the chest. The shoulders slide down the arm. That shirt was designed to be replaced, and it will be.
The Six Things I Look At
Weight and yarn. There is no single correct weight, there is only honest weight. A light tee should be light because the yarn is fine and beautiful, not because the fabric is thin to save money. A heavy tee should feel dense and solid rather than stiff and dead.
The collar. This is the tell. A collar wants a proper rib with real recovery, set on evenly, with tape across the back of the neck to hold the shape. A cheap collar is a strip of the same jersey stitched on and stretched out. Pull one gently at the store. It should want to return.
The knit. Slub yarn is spun with deliberate irregularity, so the surface has texture and takes dye unevenly. It looks alive from the first day and better after a year.
Garment dye. Cut and sew the shirt first, dye it after. Color settles into the seams, the shirt shrinks into its true shape, and it ages down instead of going flat.
Construction. Side seams instead of a tube, so the body follows a body. Clean shoulder seams. Stitching that will outlast the fabric.
Fit. A tee should sit at the shoulder point, not past it, and end near the middle of the fly. Everything else is preference.
What We Make
We do the plain shirt several ways because there is no one plain shirt. The HEAVIEST is our dense and solid version, the one you feel on your shoulders. The SLUB pocket tee has the textured hand and takes a garment dye beautifully. The Original LOGO T is the brand's oldest and simplest piece, and the one I reach for most.
Buy one great tee instead of five poor ones. Wash it cold, hang it to dry, and it will still be your favorite shirt in five years. That is the whole argument for everything we make, in the cheapest garment in the store.
A Way Of Life.
Shop the Story
Black Bear Brand HEAVIEST, The Ultimate HEAVY Tee
Black Bear Brand SLUB, The Ultimate Pocket Tee
Related Reading
How to Build a Wardrobe That Lasts a Lifetime